What readers want from historical fiction

Another fascinating blog post from author Carolyn Hughes; one of a series of posts based on her 2015 PhD thesis on the subject of authenticity in historical fiction.

People read historical fiction for a range of reasons including understanding the lives of those who lived in the past (especially those marginalised by history), immersion in a different time and place, and a desire to learn about history from stories. (Reference made here to Mary Tod’s 2013 survey of readers.) Similarly, readers require varying degrees of historical accuracy; for some a “sense of authority” rather than absolute correctness may be adequate – but only if the story is good enough.

My own reason for loving historical fiction above all other genres is the escapism afforded by immersion in another world – but a world that has tangible links with my own world (which explains why I dislike fantasy and science fiction, I suppose). Do I, as a reader, care about historical accuracy? Yes, increasingly so – because the greater one’s knowledge of a particular period (in my case WW1) the more irritated and distracted I am by errors and lazy resort to stereotypes and clich├ęs. Would I be more easily pleased when reading a novel set in another era? Up to a point, maybe – but I think my built-in bullshit-radar would still start be bleeping away in the background.

Which brings us to an interesting question; do readers of historical fiction chose their next bedtime book on the basis of period or type of story – or is choice a much more subjective and random process? Does it matter? Probably not. Harry Bingham of the Writer’s Workshop advises authors not to waste time worrying about about genre; that’s what publishers are for, apparently.

In the meantime, my job is to tell a bloody good story set in a world that is rich and believable and (to quote Carolyn Hughes) conveys “a sense of historical truth”.

Source: Authenticity in historical fiction (II)

About Hannah

Author, sometime midwife, timid mountaineer, fair weather gardener, off-road runner. Refining first novel (a Great War romantic thriller of suffragettes and soldiers) and writing the next. Passions include Africa, modern history, coffee, roses. And romance.
Aside | This entry was posted in research and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s